"This cartridge is too big."

Many printers have the option of choosing either a high yield or standard yield toner cartridge. Since high yield is usually the better deal, we deliver that. It is not our intent to confuse, but confusion sometimes is the result because the high yield cartridge may be significantly larger than the standard cartridge that was in the printer.

See the cartridges pictured below. The smaller cartridge is standard. The larger one is high yield. These fit the HP P3005 printer.

Go ahead and install the cartridge, even though it looks entirely too large to fit. You will probably be surprised.

And you'll save even more money.